Choke chains and other mistakes when working with dog aggression

I have tremendous success with my aggression cases and have been helping dogs overcome aggression since 2002. There are strategies that you can use that can make the situation worse.
I want you to avoid doing that and help your dog become more comfortable faster.

Everyone has their own views about curing aggression. A surprising number of trainers recommend abusive methods such as choke chains and shock collars. Those same trainers think that you have to treat aggression with aggression. "Show the dog who is boss" or be the "pack leader" or "dominant". I urge you to look beyond the fear tactics they use to scare you into leaving your common sense behind and hire them to beat up your dog. If it feels wrong and abusive, it probably is.

Don't let anyone tell you that you need to beat up or "break" your dog to cure him of his aggression.

Follows are some mistakes that I see when working with aggression. Want to join in on the conversation? Leave comments. I won't be shy responding.

Mistake - Using choke chains, prong collars, shock collars, or other positive punishment.

This is often incorrectly referred to as "negative reinforcement". Positive punishment is the act of adding something aversive in order to stop a behavior.

With aggression, some trainers recommend using a choke chain or shock collar and adding pain when a dog is aggressive.

Why it is a mistake.

Similar to alpha rolls, the dog can seem to be "cured" because they stop showing aggression, but the underlying anxiety can still be present. It is also unnecessary and abusive to add physical pain to any animal that is under stress. It is unfair, irresponsible and unnecessary to add pain to a dog when he is uncomfortable. Move him away, manage him better and use systematic desensitization to build confidence and get him more comfortable with the situation.

I equate punishing a dog for showing signs of aggression to punishing a person that is afraid of spiders. Just imagine if you were afraid of spiders, a spider fell on your head when you walked through it's web and you started screaming. Then, someone shocked you or choked you. You are responding to a stimulus (the spider) in way that you can't help and punished for it. If this happened, would you become more comfortable around spiders? I doubt it.

That is similar to a dog that is afraid of another dog or a person. They growl or bark because they are afraid. If they are choked or shocked when this happens, they will continue to be afraid of the approaching stimulus, and also afraid to show signals. If any animal is afraid, positive punishment can stop the animal from showing outward signs of discomfort, but the anxiety has not been addressed, except to mask it.

Then, that dog reaches a point that the dog can't help but to attack. It seems like they are attacking out of nowhere, but their signals were suppressed, so it seems like that. Not good.

Note: I am 100% against using choke chains, prong collars or shock collars in all dog training situations. Period. Comments? Please comment below.

Mistake - Moving too quickly or inappropriate expectations.

I was at a second appointment recently with a client that has a newly adopted dog that exhibits aggression towards people and dogs. She had bitten two people in the first week in her new home with little damage.

After working slowly and systematically during the first session, we made a lot of progress while I assessed Tulip's anxiety and learned her signals. By the end of the session, I could walk slowly towards her up to about 10 feet away while she remained calm the entire time. 

The second appointment we continued working and I was able to give Tulip a few treats from my outstretched hand, while Tulip was on leash the entire time.

I advised my client to move her away at some point to a distance of 5 feet. He said he was surprised that I was still cautious at this stage. She seemed fine and was taking treats gently out of my hand. 

The reason that I did not push too quickly and try and pet Tulip is that I did not want to put her in a situation where she felt nervous and that she had to defend herself by growling, barking or biting.

Aggression has obvious signals such as growling and biting, but before that happens, a dog starts to get anxious. In other words, if a dog would bite me if I touched her collar, she is not completely calm all the way until I touch her collar and then she gets instantly anxious and bites me. There is a point that she sees me approaching when she starts to get anxious.

If I push too quickly, I am proving to the dog that she needs to keep an eye on me and that I am a threat. 

I want dogs to not care about the trigger (person, dog, car, bicycle, etc.) that is currently causing stress. If a dog sees me in her house and I always push her until she shows obvious signals, then she will at some point start to get anxious as soon as she sees me.

"There's that guy, I need to be cautious, I know at some point he is going to come over here . . . oh, he stood up, is he coming over? He looked at me, this is it . . ." If that is our relationship then she will never learn to be completely calm when I am in the room or it might take a really long time.

Desensitization is working below the dog's stress level so she is not repeatedly thrust into defense or attack mode. 

Go slowly. Pay attention to your dog's signals, and it will pay off.

Oh yeah, did I mention you don't need shock collars or choke chains? You don't.

Latest Blog Posts

How to safely take your dog to a dog park

With summer weather finally here in Chicago, it is time to start thinking about more frequent trips to the dog park. You might feel uneasy when your dog plays with other dogs. Hopefully this...

  • Jeff Millman
  • 2011-05-20 15:42:00
  • Hits 16518

How long should dog training sessions last?

Did you know it is better to practice short training sessions and stop when your dog still wants more? This strategy will keep training interesting and you will avoid over training.
  • Jeff Millman
  • 2011-05-06 19:36:00
  • Hits 28557

Positive reinforcement dog training strategies

Did you know that there are different styles of training within the positive reinforcement "camp"? There are trainers that only use one style and others (like myself) use many different strategies...

  • Jeff Millman
  • 2011-05-09 12:48:00
  • Hits 26497

Your dog is acting weird? It might be a physical problem

I received two calls this week that that reminded me about the importance of making sure a dog is physically healthy before I recommend training strategies. One call was in regards to a 3-year old...

  • Jeff Millman
  • 2011-05-15 04:06:15
  • Hits 27313

The PETA Founder - I Am An Animal: The Story of Ingrid Newkirk and PETA

I just finished watching the documentary about Ingrid Newkirk, the co-founder of PETA. I really did not know much about her or her organization before this except for the various news stories that...

  • Jeff Millman
  • 2011-05-17 14:21:00
  • Hits 56811

Your dog is stubborn? Here are some tips.

Stubborn is used frequently to describe dogs that don't perform a task that is asked of them. Maybe the dog is pulling on his leash, maybe he doesn't lie down when cued, or maybe he lies down when...

  • Jeff Millman
  • 2011-05-28 12:57:00
  • Hits 27640

How old should a dog be before he can be out of the crate?

Wouldn't it be great if you could just sit a dog down and say, "Welcome to the house. Let's have an arrangement. I will walk you, play with you, feed you good food and give you medical care. The...

  • Jeff Millman
  • 2011-05-30 15:04:00
  • Hits 28994

Should you use alpha rolls? No.

When I am working with my clients, I focus on determining what strategies are most effective with each individual dog. I have found certain techniques to be extremely effective and I also see...

  • Jeff Millman
  • 2011-05-27 03:34:01
  • Hits 23409

Do you say, "No!" to your dog alot?

"No" (which means don't jump on the guests)."No" (which means don't chew on the couch)."No" (which means stop barking)Sound familiar?
  • Jeff Millman
  • 2011-05-03 19:10:49
  • Hits 17829

Common dog training questions

I frequently hear very similar questions from multiple clients. I also have random dog training thoughts that come to mind that might not lend themselves to a complete blog post. So, I thought I...

  • Jeff Millman
  • 2011-05-25 14:15:00
  • Hits 39681